Gina Miller calls for investigation into “price collusion”

Gina MillerGina Miller, the vocal supporter of passive investment, has called on UK financial and competition authorities to investigate whether there is price collusion within the active fund management industry. Backing the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), which is concerned there is “limited price competition” between active UK funds, Miller said 70% by number and 73% by value of the UK’s actively managed equity funds had an identical annual management charge (AMC) of 0.75%. Miller, famous for her legal challenge to the UK government’s plans to trigger Brexit without a vote by MPs, said the finding proved there was “no genuine price competition” within the sector and she wants the FCA and the Competition and Markets Authority to investigate. SCM Direct, a wealth manager Miller co-founded and that invests client money in passive funds, carried out the research. Miller said that evidence of price clustering for active equity funds at both 1% and 0.75% for clean share classes flew in the face of claims from fund groups that they competed to produce the best investment returns. “This is not only to the detriment of UK investors but also contravenes the FCA’s ‘Treating Customers Fairly’ principle,” she said of the alleged collusion. “Different products, with different ingredients and vastly different track records should command different pricing.” Miller added that the Retail Distribution Review of 2012 had been expected to lead to lower fund manager charges for active funds, but research from the last five years showed that charges had not changed since the review. SCM claimed that if the AMC charged by firms reduced by 0.1% a year – from 0.75% to 0.65% – UK savers and investors would be £488 million (€565 million) better off every year. Miller said the research also found clear evidence that large funds were not passing on economies of scale to customers through lower prices and were even more likely than smaller funds to charge an identical price. Last month a former asset management sector leader from the UK financial regulator, Dan Waters, said that he fundamentally disagreed with the regulator’s claim that the UK fund industry is uncompetitive, saying that the UK fund market has the “hallmarks of a highly competitive industry” and that fund fees were steadily falling. ©2017 funds europe

Sponsored Profiles

SPONSORED FEATURE: Alternative thinking

Mar 16, 2017

Portfolio Manager Davide Cataldo discusses the results of the Pioneer Investments’ survey on liquid alternatives and how investors can be encouraged to increase their allocation.

SPONSORED FEATURE: Interest rate risk hedging: Swapping to other options

Mar 16, 2017

Heightened margin requirements for cleared and uncleared OTC derivatives pose a challenge for legitimate hedging activities and are driving financial institutions to explore alternative hedging...

SPONSORED FEATURE: Why blockchain could be the fund industry’s next Ford Model T

Mar 16, 2017

Blockchain aims to radically change the way investors can access funds, says Olivier Portenseigne, Managing Director and Chief Commercial Officer of Fundsquare.

SPONSORED FEATURE: Open architecture: In need of protection

Mar 16, 2017

Greater efficiency must be embraced to ensure regulatory changes do not destroy choice for fund buyers, says Bernard Tancré of Clearstream.

Executive Interviews

INTERVIEW: Finding managers that can (and do)

Apr 18, 2017

Fabrice Kremer, a fund selector at Banque de Luxembourg Investments, has berated fundamental managers for failing to beat indices, but he remains committed to active funds. He speaks to Nick...

JERSEY INTERVIEW: ‘A steady sort of place’

Mar 21, 2017

The chief executive of Jersey Finance is keen to portray the island as a stable, trustworthy jurisdiction. He talks to George Mitton.


ROUNDTABLE: The issue is perception

Mar 21, 2017

Our panel discuss tax transparency, the elegance of private placement and why Jersey could do more to promote itself. Chaired by Tom Cowsill in Saint Helier.


Mar 07, 2017

Funds Europe speaks to leading Luxembourg industry figures about the growing regulatory demands on asset servicers and how to remain profitable in spite of major investments in technology.